Picking the Best Ice Cream Maker

Getting the best ice cream maker is no easy choice as these appliances can have a hefty price tag. Yet, they are worth every penny as nothing beats the decadent taste of homemade ice cream. Getting a homemade ice cream maker is great for those looking to make healthier sweets as well.

As there are many ice cream makers on the market, we decided to ease the decision making process for everyone by reviewing these machines and providing our top picks.

1. Whynter ICM-15LS Automatic Ice Cream Maker

ICM-15LS Whynter Ice Cream Maker – Stainless Steel

  • Award winning ice cream machine that does not require pre-freezing!
  • Stainless steel. Made from durable material!
  • BPA-free aluminum bowl and blade for easy storage and cleaning.
  • LCD, built-in audible timer.

Specifications:

  • Capacity: 1.6 quarts (1.5 liters).
  • Temperature range: -0.4°F to -31°F (-18°C to -35°C)
  • Power consumption: 150W / 2.4A
  • Dimensions: 18.5” W x 11” L x 10” H (47cm W x 28cm L x 25.4cm H)
  • Weight: 27lbs (12kg)

Things to love:

  • Compressor-based: Unlike bowl-based ice cream makers, there’s no need to worry about temperature fluctuations over time.
  • Freezes quickly: Whytner Ice Cream Maker is definitely a great choice for those looking to reduce the time they spend in the kitchen. Going from nothing to delicious ice cream only takes from 30 to 60 minutes.
  • Easy to clean: Due to the design of the homemade ice cream machine, cleaning is effortless. Removing the bowl and blade and cleaning everything up by hand will only take a minute.
  • Simple to use: There’s no need to go about a complex ice cream making process – simply add the ingredients and turn the machine on.

Possible issues:

  • Fairly noisy: While this home ice cream maker won’t sound like a passing helicopter, it can still disrupt activities like reading or watching TV.

Final remarks:

Whytner can definitely rank as the best ice cream maker out there. All of the possible drawbacks can be easily solved in most cases and the ease with which it produces ice cream is unmatched. If you are looking for a reliable homemade ice cream maker, Whytner won’t disappoint.

2. Cuisinart ICE-100 Ice Cream Maker

Cuisinart Compressor-based Gelato and Ice Cream Maker

  • Fully automatic and compressor-based 
  • Different paddles for gelato and ice cream
  • BPA-free materials
  • Countdown timer with a 10 min “keep cool” feature

Specifications:

  • Capacity: 1.5 quarts (1.4 liters)
  • Dimensions: 16.73” W x 12.00” L x 9.33” H (42.5cm W x 30.5 cm L x 23.7cm H)
  • Weight: 27.2lbs (12.3kg)

Things to love:

  • Compressor-based: There won’t be any need to fiddle with bowls or putting things into a freezer overnight.
  • Decent freezing time: Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker has a default setting of 60 minutes. That should suffice even for the most tenacious ice cream bases.
  • Simple to use: Not a lot of parts or complex operation comes with this ice cream maker. Just add the ingredients and start the machine.

Possible issues:

  • Somewhat noisy: Noise volumes might differ slightly based on the contents in the machine but it can still be a little disrupting.
  • Can be difficult to clean: If the machine is overfilled or left on for too long, ice cream will spill into harder to reach parts of the machine. Cleaning could then become a chore.

Final remarks:

Cuisinart definitely earns its spot as a top rated ice cream maker. Making delicious gelato and ice cream is incredibly fun and simple with it. While it holds a bigger price tag than the Whytner model, it will still be worth every penny for those willing to invest.

3. Lello 4080 Musso Lussino Ice Cream Machine

Musso Lussino Homemade Ice Cream Maker

  • Fully automatic and compressor-based
  • Stainless steel materials
  • Timer
  • Controls for different freezing options

Specifications:

  • Capacity: 1.5 quarts (1.4 liters)
  • Dimensions: 17.72” W x 11.81” L x 11.81” H (45 cm W x 30 cm L x 30 cm H)
  • Weight: 38lbs (17.2kg)

Things to love:

  • Easy to use: Lello Musso Lussino Ice Cream Machine is dead simple to use. There are just two buttons and a timer knob. Plop the ingredients in and turn the machine on.
  • High quality ice cream: Due to the design and quality of parts, this homemade ice cream maker will produce the highest quality goods out of all the other machines.
  • Quick freeze: Making ice cream and gelato takes only about 30 minutes and it can produce 1.5 quarts in total.
  • No ice crystals: Lello Musso is definitely one of the best electric ice cream makers as it avoids a common issue with most machines – ice crystals. Almost all ice cream will be crystal-free!
  • Easy to clean: This homemade ice cream maker can be easily dismantled and cleaned. Due to the stainless steel parts, cleaning will be a breeze.

Possible issues:

  • Expensive: Musso Lussino is basically the Mercedes-Benz of ice cream machines. Expect a hefty price tag to pay for the high quality.
  • Heavy: Out of all our reviewed best ice cream makers, this one weighs the most. Lugging around a 17.2kg machine isn’t going to be a lot of fun. Be sure to find a good place for the machine in the kitchen and keep it there.
  • Short warranty: Lello Musso Lussino grants a 1 year warranty. For an expensive machine that might be a little too short.

Final Remarks:

Want to make ice cream that blows store-bought confectionary out of the water? This is the best ice cream maker for that. With its beautiful design, high quality production, and quick freeze time, you’ll be running local stores out of business!

4. Cuisinart ICE-30 Ice Cream Maker

cuisinart-ice

Cuisinart ICE-30BCP1 Ice Cream Maker

  • Fully automatic
  • Stainless steel housing; BPA-free
  • Bowl-based
  • Two quart freezer bowl

Specifications:

  • Capacity: 2 quarts (1.9 liters)
  • Dimensions: 8.25” W x 8.00” L x 11.25” H (21 cm W x 20 cm L x 28 cm H)
  • Weight: 3.20lbs (1.45kg)

Things to love:

  • Cheap: Out of all the homemade ice cream makers, this one is definitely the least expensive. If you’re not looking to break your wallet wide open, Cuisinart ICE-30 is the choice.
  • Lightweight: Weighing in at just 3.20lbs (1.45kgs), handling the ice cream machine in question will be dead simple.
  • Small: Everyone, even those with the smallest kitchen in the world, will be able to find a nice place for this top rated ice cream maker.

Possible issues:

  • Bowl-based: Homemade ice cream makers without a compressor require additional preparation time. Bowls need to be frozen overnight in the freezer in order to produce ice cream.
  • Long freeze time: With the added preparation time, this ice cream machine will definitely need some time to make your favorite confectionary. Even with the required preparation, making ice cream will take up to 60 minutes.
  • Limited chill-down time: You have to start with ice-cold ingredients. Room-temperature ingredients will warm up the machine too quickly which will result in disappointing ice cream.
  • Can only produce 1 bucket per day: Unless you buy a second bowl, due to the freezing requirement, you’ll only be able to produce 1 bucket of ice cream per day.

Final remarks:

If you’re looking to see if a homemade ice cream maker would be suitable for your goals without breaking the bank, Cuisinart ICE-30B is a decent choice. Out of all bowl-based top rated ice cream makers, this one takes the cake. If you already love making homemade ice cream, we recommend picking a more expensive option out of our best ice cream maker list.

Picking the Best Ice Cream Maker

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to top